The rise of online marketplaces has revolutionized the way we shop for a wide range of products. From electronics to clothing to collectibles, you can find almost anything with just a few clicks. However, a recent study conducted by researchers at Cornell University has shed light on a disturbing trend: the illegal trade of rare and endangered insects and spiders on platforms like eBay and Amazon.

This illicit market allows buyers to easily purchase exotic and threatened species, often commanding high prices due to their scarcity and protected status, and further driving these species towards extinction, Mongabay reports. The findings of this study raise significant concerns about the lack of oversight and enforcement when it comes to the online sale of endangered species.

Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Auckland War Memorial Museum Tāmaki Paenga Hira, License: CC BY-SA 4.0 DEED
The online market for endangered insects spans various species, including butterflies, beetles, and spiders.

Unveiling the Online Butterfly Market

In September 2020, Zhengyang Wang and his colleagues from Harvard University embarked on a groundbreaking research project. They monitored the sales of dead butterflies on eBay for a year, utilizing automation to search through 150,000 butterfly names present on the platform. The results were alarming – over 50,000 transactions involving 3,767 different species were recorded, accounting for nearly a fifth of all known butterfly species.

Photo: Papilio chikae male, Wikimedia Commons / Anaxibia, License: CC BY 3.0 US DEED
The accessibility and ease of purchasing endangered insects online contribute to their illegal trade.

The Astonishing Accessibility of Endangered Species

While the study focused on butterflies, it is not an isolated issue. The researchers from Cornell University conducted a broader search across various online marketplaces, including Amazon, eBay, Etsy, and Alibaba, Ars Technica reports. Their goal was to identify if rare, threatened, or regulated species were available for sale. The results were astounding. The team found 79 species listed across three key conservation lists: the Convention on International Trade of Endangered Species of Flora and Fauna (CITES), the International Union for Conservation of Nature's (IUCN) Red List of Threatened Species, and the U.S. Endangered Species List.

Among the species discovered for sale were those categorized as critically endangered on the Red List. For instance, a Gooty sapphire tarantula was listed on eBay for $232.50, while a Cyprus beetle was priced at $1,100. Even more concerning was the illegal sale of a Luzon peacock swallowtail butterfly on Amazon for approximately $110, a species that is a popular target for smugglers. The most expensive insect found was an Ornithoptera allottei birdwing butterfly, listed on eBay for a staggering $3,850. These exorbitant prices indicate the demand for endangered species and the potential profits associated with their illicit trade.

Photo: Pixabay
Endangered insects are often sold at exorbitant prices due to their rarity and protected status.

The Alarming Ease of Trading Endangered Species Online

The ease with which endangered species are openly sold online is deeply concerning. Juan Pablo Jordan, one of the student co-authors of the study, expressed his astonishment at the accessibility of listings.

“It was really astonishing how easily endangered species are openly being sold online,” says Juan Pablo Jordan, a student co-author who is now a doctoral student in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology. “It was also surprising how accessible the [endangered species] listings are to find and the complacency of the sale platforms that are essentially supporting the trade of at-risk species that are protected by law.”

The platforms themselves, such as eBay and Amazon, play a significant role in supporting the trade of at-risk species that are protected by law. The lack of stringent measures and effective oversight allows sellers to exploit the demand for endangered insects and spiders, perpetuating a market that undermines conservation efforts.

Photo: Pixabay
The sale of endangered insects on online platforms is a global issue.

Ecological Consequences and the Need for Better Regulation

The consequences of the illegal online trade of endangered insects and spiders extend beyond the immediate impact on individual species. Many of these creatures play vital roles in ecosystems as pollinators or as natural pest controllers. For instance, the sale of ladybugs released for pest control purposes can have unintended effects if the insects are diseased, of the wrong strain, or not suited for specific regions, Treehugger reports. Releasing such compromised insects into the wild can harm larger populations and disrupt the ecological balance.

To combat this issue, there is an urgent need for better enforcement of regulations surrounding the online sale of rare insects. The researchers behind the study have shared their findings with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the agency responsible for combating the illegal trade of species. However, limited resources hinder effective monitoring and enforcement.

John Losey, the lead author of the study, proposes considering insects that provide services as "livestock" and placing them under the regulation of the U.S. Department of Agriculture. This approach could help mitigate the unregulated sale of these valuable creatures and safeguard their populations in the wild.

Photo: Pixabay
The sale of endangered insects on online platforms threatens their populations and disrupts ecosystems.

The Response of Online Marketplaces

Following the publication of the study, eBay and Amazon, the two major platforms implicated in the sale of endangered insects and spiders, responded to the findings. An eBay spokesperson emphasized their policy against the sale of endangered or threatened species, stating that they employ block filter algorithms to prevent prohibited items from being listed. They also highlighted their commitment to removing any listings that violate these policies and taking enforcement actions against sellers who breach the rules.

Similarly, an Amazon spokesperson reiterated that third-party sellers on their platform must adhere to selling guidelines and comply with applicable laws when offering animals or animal-related products. They emphasized the prohibition of selling endangered species and pledged to investigate the non-compliant listings and take appropriate action.

Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Natural History Museum, London, License: CC BY-SA 4.0 DEED
Illegal listings of endangered insects can be found on multiple online marketplaces, not limited to eBay.

Protecting Endangered Insects and Spiders in the Digital Age

The illegal trade of endangered butterflies and spiders on online platforms represents a significant threat to global biodiversity. The ease of accessing these rare species and the exorbitant prices they command underscore the urgent need for stricter regulations and better enforcement.

The study conducted by Cornell University researchers serves as a wake-up call to the authorities, online marketplaces, and society as a whole. By taking immediate action to monitor and mitigate the online exploitation of endangered species, we can protect these vital creatures and preserve the delicate balance of our ecosystems for future generations.

Click below to make a difference!