In late 2022, the Monticello Nuclear Generating Plant in Minnesota leaked hundreds of thousands of gallons of radioactive water into the groundwater near the Mississippi River. Despite reassurances from officials, the long-term impact on the surrounding environment and wildlife raises pressing questions.

Tritium, a radioactive isotope in the water, has been linked to significant environmental risks when it enters ecosystems. Given the scale of the leak and the plant's proximity to the Mississippi River, concerns extend from public safety to wildlife health, with some effects already visible.

Monticello Leak Timeline and Response

The Monticello plant leak first surfaced in November 2022 when officials at Xcel Energy, which operates the plant, detected that roughly 400,000 gallons of water containing tritium had seeped from a pipe between buildings. The company quickly notified state regulators, who reportedly opted to delay informing the public to gather more details.

As CBS News reports, The news broke four months later in March 2023, sparking criticism from residents and environmental advocates about the transparency of the plant’s safety protocols and the speed of its response.

Xcel Energy, in coordination with state and federal regulators, contained the initial leak and rerouted the radioactive water back into the plant’s internal water treatment system. Yet, a temporary solution soon failed, prompting the plant to power down in late March, MPR News reports. The facility’s shutdown led to an unexpected consequence: a drop in the surrounding water temperature, which killed over 200 fish in the Mississippi River.

Environmental Concerns Over Tritium Contamination

Tritium, while emitting low-energy radiation that cannot penetrate human skin, poses dangers if ingested in large amounts. The radioactive element, often released as a byproduct of nuclear plants, has a half-life of approximately 12 years, during which it gradually decays, emitting beta particles that scientists link to long-term health risks, according to the Minnesota Health Department. Tritium can enter the body through contaminated water or food and, when present in ecosystems, may persist in plants and animals, raising concerns about its accumulation in the food chain.

The leak’s immediate aftermath did not show tritium outside plant grounds, and officials report that the tritium levels measured in groundwater around the Monticello site are within safe federal guidelines, NPR reports. Nevertheless, given that the plant sits directly upstream from major waterways, environmentalists worry about potential long-term seepage into the river, which could expose fish and other aquatic species to harmful radiation levels.

Local anglers and wildlife advocates are especially wary, as studies indicate that prolonged exposure to tritium can cause genetic mutations and impact reproductive health in wildlife.

Fish Kills and Ecosystem Imbalance

A more visible consequence of the plant’s temporary shutdown has already materialized: a mass fish kill. Following the plant’s power-down, the sudden change in water temperature reportedly shocked over 230 fish to death, the Associated Press reports.

According to the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA), bass, catfish, and carp, accustomed to warmer waters from the plant’s cooling systems, succumbed to the abrupt temperature drop.

The river’s fish populations have adapted to consistent warmer temperatures maintained by the plant’s cooling discharge. Changes in water temperature, especially sudden fluctuations, disrupt species balance, threatening biodiversity in affected areas. As CBS News reports, a continuous flow of warm water can alter fish behavior and migration patterns, encouraging population densities that are unsustainable in normal temperature conditions. The shutdown highlights the plant’s environmental influence and illustrates the challenges of balancing nuclear energy with aquatic ecosystem stability.

Long-term Wildlife Impact: Birds, Mammals, and Aquatic Species

While immediate reports have emphasized the leak’s effect on fish, concerns about other wildlife near the Monticello plant are growing. Birds, amphibians, and mammals that frequent the Mississippi River may also face exposure if tritium-contaminated water enters their habitat, MPR News reports. Radiological contamination in animals can lead to compromised immune systems, reduced fertility, and abnormalities over time. Many species in the area, including migratory birds and native amphibians, could suffer from prolonged radiation exposure if tritium or other contaminants spread into the river.

Minnesota’s MPCA has committed to ongoing monitoring, with routine testing of the air, groundwater, and river around the plant. As MPCA Assistant Commissioner Kirk Koudelka told Asssociated Press, the agency aims to ensure that any signs of radiological contamination receive swift attention to protect both human and environmental health. Yet, if the tritium plume were to migrate further, wildlife habitats downstream could face contamination.

Lessons for Future Management and Transparency

The delayed public notification of the Monticello leak has prompted questions about transparency and public accountability. Although Xcel Energy and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission claim the leak posed no immediate risk, critics argue that residents should have been informed earlier.

Chris Clark, president of Xcel Energy–Minnesota, acknowledged the need for improved transparency, telling NPR, “We have an opportunity to do a better job being transparent with our neighbors.”

Xcel has begun to recover the tritium-laced water and is exploring long-term containment solutions, including aboveground storage tanks or lined retention ponds. These efforts underscore the complexity of managing radioactive leaks, especially in facilities near sensitive environments like the Mississippi River. Environmental advocates emphasize the importance of robust contingency plans and quick action to prevent potential disasters, urging greater regulatory oversight, MPR News reports.

The Monticello leak has revealed challenges at the intersection of nuclear energy and environmental stewardship. While officials have reassured the public of safety, the incident has ignited discussions about the potential risks of radioactive leaks in natural waterways.

With the Mississippi River and its ecosystems at stake, environmental groups advocate for ongoing vigilance and greater transparency to prevent future risks. The Monticello case serves as a reminder that balancing energy needs with environmental protection requires proactive measures and a commitment to accountability.

Click below to take action for the Mississippi River and its wildlife!